Comparison of the Effectiveness of a Gymnastics Training Program and Teaching Games for Understanding on Improving Gross Motor Skills in Children Aged 4 to 11 Years
Keywords:
Teaching Games for Understanding (TGfU), gymnastics training, gross motor skills, children, physical education, motor skill developmentAbstract
Objective: This study aimed to compare the effectiveness of a gymnastics training program and the Teaching Games for Understanding (TGfU) approach in enhancing gross motor skills among children aged 4 to 11 years.
Methods and Materials: A quasi-experimental design with a pre-test and post-test structure was employed. Sixty girls aged 4 to 11 years from Mashhad, who had no prior experience in gymnastics, were recruited using convenience sampling. Participants were randomly assigned to either the gymnastics training group or the TGfU group, each further divided into two age-based subgroups (4\u20137 years and 8\u201311 years). Gross motor skills were assessed using the Bruininks-Oseretsky Test of Motor Proficiency (BOT-2). Data were analyzed using descriptive statistics and a one-way multivariate analysis of covariance (MANCOVA) to determine differences between the groups.
Findings: Both the gymnastics training program and TGfU approach significantly improved gross motor skills. However, the TGfU group showed a greater increase in mean post-test scores compared to the gymnastics group. ANCOVA results confirmed a statistically significant difference in motor skill improvement between the two interventions, with TGfU exhibiting a stronger overall effect. These findings highlight TGfU\u2019s ability to integrate cognitive engagement and contextual learning, resulting in greater enhancements in motor skill development.
Conclusion: The TGfU approach demonstrated superior effectiveness in enhancing gross motor skills compared to gymnastics training. While gymnastics promotes strength and balance through structured routines, TGfU fosters intrinsic motivation and cognitive understanding.
Downloads
References
1. Arias AG, Claver F, Práxedes A, Álvarez FdV, Harvey S.
Autonomy Support, Motivational Climate, Enjoyment and Perceived
Competence in Physical Education: Impact of a Hybrid Teaching
Games for Understanding/Sport Education Unit. European Physical
Education Review. 2018;26(1):36-53. [DOI]
2. Arias AG, Diloy-Peña S, Sevil‐Serrano J, García-González
L, Abós Á. A Hybrid TGfU/SE Volleyball Teaching Unit for
Enhancing Motivation in Physical Education: A Mixed-Method
Approach. International Journal of Environmental Research and Public
Health. 2020;18(1):110. [PMID: 33375232] [PMCID: PMC7795743]
[DOI]
3. Arias AG, Harvey S, Cárceles A, Práxedes A, Álvarez FdV.
Impact of a Hybrid TGfU-Sport Education Unit on Student Motivation
in Physical Education. Plos One. 2017;12(6):e0179876. [PMID:
28658267] [PMCID: PMC5489183] [DOI]
4. Arias AG, Harvey S, García-Herreros F, González-Víllora
S, Práxedes A, Domínguez AM. Effect of a Hybrid Teaching Games
for Understanding/Sport Education Unit on Elementary Students’ SelfDetermined Motivation in Physical Education. European Physical
Education Review. 2020;27(2):366-83. [PMID: 28658267] [PMCID:
PMC5489183] [DOI]
5. Mnejja K, García‐Soidan JL, Romo‐Perez V, Sahli S.
Postural balance under sensory manipulation predicted fine and gross
motor skills in children from 5 to 6 years of age. Acta Paediatrica.
2023;112(7):1524-9. [PMID: 36951623] [DOI]
6. Li Y. The Effects of the Teaching Games for Understanding
(TGFU) Mode Adopted in a College Basketball Program. Journal of
Education and Learning. 2024;13(4):134. [DOI]
7. Aryanti S, Azhar S, Tangkudung J, Yusmawati Y, Ilahi BR,
Okilanda A. Teaching Games for Understanding (TGfU) Model
Learning for Overhead Pass Volleyball in Elementary School Students.
International Journal of Human Movement and Sports Sciences.
2022;10(4):677-82. [DOI]
8. Nathan S. Badminton Instructional in Malaysian Schools: A
Comparative Analysis of TGfU and SDT Pedagogical Models.
Springerplus. 2016;5(1). [PMID: 27516953] [PMCID: PMC4967053]
[DOI]
9. Baumgarten S, Pagnano-Richardson K. Educational
gymnastics: Enhancing children's physical literacy. Journal of Physical
Education, Recreation & Dance. 2010;81(4):18-25. [DOI]
10. Hafez R. Effect of Brain Gym on manipulating skills and
balance for beginners in rhythmic gymnastics. Science, Movement, and
Health. 2017;17(1):66-72.
11. Semão FA, Ana Claudia de Souza H, Bertin LD, Oliveira
RFd. Proprioception Influence in the Balance of Gymnastics Rhythmic
Postural Athletes. Manual Therapy Posturology & Rehabilitation
Journal. 2015:1-5. [DOI]
12. Saleh V, Afroundeh R, Siahkouhian M, Asadi A. Effect of
an 8-Week Anaerobic Gymnastics Training on Static, Dynamic
Balance and Body Composition in Obese and Normal-Weight
Children. Journal of Pediatric Nursing. 2021;8(2):81-91.
13. Moreno FJ, Reina R, Luis V, Sabido R. Visual search
strategies in experienced and inexperienced gymnastic coaches.
Perceptual and Motor skills. 2002;95(3):901-2. [PMID: 12509194]
[DOI]
14. Chow J, Davids K, Button C, Renshaw I, Shuttleworth R,
Uehara L. Nonlinear pedagogy: implications for teaching games for
understanding (TGfU). TGfU: simply good pedagogy: understanding
a complex challenge2009. p. 131-43
15. Booth E, Kokkranikal J, Burukina OA. Russian Artistic
Gymnastics as a Sports Tourism Product: Some Observations and a
Research Agenda. 2015:81-96. [PMID: PMC4491260] [DOI]
16. Jarrett K, Harvey S. Similar, but Not the Same: Comparing
the Game Based Approaches of Teaching Games for Understanding
(TGfU) and Game Sense. Ejournal De La Recherche Sur L
Intervention en Éducation Physique Et Sport -Ejrieps. 2016(38). [DOI]
17. Wang L, Ha AS. Mentoring in TGfU Teaching. European
Physical Education Review. 2012;18(1):47-61. [DOI]
18. Bagøien TE, Halvari H, Nesheim H. Self-Determined
Motivation in Physical Education and Its Links to Motivation for
Leisure-Time Physical Activity, Physical Activity, and Well-Being in
General. Perceptual and Motor Skills. 2010;111(2):407-32. [PMID:
21162443] [DOI]
19. Claver F, Martínez-Aranda LM, Conejero M, Gil-Arias A.
Motivation, Discipline, and Academic Performance in Physical
Education: A Holistic Approach From Achievement Goal and SelfDetermination Theories. Frontiers in Psychology. 2020;11. [PMID:
32903702] [PMCID: PMC7438928] [DOI]
20. Gil-Arias A, Diloy-Peña S, Sevil-Serrano J, GarcíaGonzález L, Abós Á. A hybrid tgfu/se volleyball teaching unit for
enhancing motivation in physical education: A mixed-method
approach. International Journal of Environmental Research and Public
Health. 2021;18(1):110. [PMID: 33375232] [PMCID: PMC7795743]
21. Debien PB, Timoteo TF, Gabbett TJ, Bara Filho MG.
Training-Load Management in Rhythmic Gymnastics: Practices and
Perceptions of Coaches, Medical Staff, and Gymnasts. Int J Sports
Physiol Perform. 2022;17(4):530-40. [PMID: 35016155] [DOI]
22. López-Lemus I. Could the Hybridization of the SE/TGfU
Pedagogical Models Be an Alternative for Learning Sports and
Promoting Health? School Context Study. Children. 2023;10(5):877.
[PMID: 37238425] [PMCID: PMC10217109] [DOI]
23. Gustian U. Effectiveness of Teaching Games for
Understanding (TGfU): Using a Modified Kasti Game to Stimulate
Elementary School Students’ Motor Skills. Edu Sportivo Indonesian
Journal of Physical Education. 2024;5(1):54-63. [DOI]
24. Pan Y, Huang C-H, Hsu W-T. A Comparison of the
Learning Effects Between TGfU-SE and TGfU on Learning
Motivation, Sport Enjoyment, Responsibility, and Game Performance
in Physical Education. Frontiers in Psychology. 2023;14. [PMID:
37519367] [PMCID: PMC10374309] [DOI]
25. Pratama A. The Application of TGFU Learning in
Volleyball Upper Passing Learning. Journal of Social Work and
Science Education. 2023;4(3):83-9. [DOI]
26. Bruijn AGMd, Greeff JWd, Temlali TY, Oosterlaan J,
Smith JK, Hartman E. Objectively Measured Physical Activity During
Primary School Physical Education Predicts Intrinsic Motivation
Independently of Academic Achievement Level. British Journal of
Educational Psychology. 2022;93(S1):90-112. [PMID: 35726452]
[DOI]
Downloads
Additional Files
Published
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2024 Sepideh Shakerian , Kiana Hosseini Shakib , Meysam Rezaee (Author)
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License.
